I published a rough draft of this "manifesto" a few days ago but decided to remove it, resolving to finish it first before I lay it down again before the feet of the world. I've realized it's unsettlingly personal, but, well, there may be people who want to understand.
Heading for Bunker Hill While watching Good Will Hunting (again) a few days ago, I realized that, while I might wish I had Matt Damon's character's gifts, it is actually Sean Maguire (played by Robin Williams) to whom I can relate, more so today than when I first watched the movie. Sean teaches at Bunker Hill Community College and agrees to counsel Will Hunting when other high-priced shrinks had surrendered. In the movie, he has a shouting match with his former classmate, MIT professor and Fields Medal winner Gerald Lambeau.
Gerald tells him, "Don't infect him (Will) with the idea that it's okay to quit. That it's okay to be a failure, because it's not okay!" He points out that Sean is "smarter than us then and you're smarter than us now" and accuses Sean of being "angry at me for being successful, for being what you could have been.... You resent me. And I'm not going to apologize for any success that I've had.... Ask yourself if you want Will to feel that way for the rest of his life, to feel like a failure."
And Sean explodes, "That's it. That's why I don't come to the goddamn reunions! Becaue I can't stand the look in your eye when you see me! You think I'm a failure! I know who I am. I'm proud of who I am. And all of you, you think I'm some kind of pity case!"
For some reason, their exchange reminded me of the first few months following the August board. At first it was the norm to vacillate, to be doing nothing substantial, to have no idea where one was headed. But as days turned into weeks that turned into months, I learned to hate bumping into anyone from the medical world. I would inevitably be asked, "
Asa na man ka ron?" and, when I answered, I would as inevitably be asked why I hadn't gone into training yet. There was no acceptable answer of acceptable length -- the short answer was unsatisfactory; the long version would be too good to waste on mere acquaintances whose genuine interest, beyond mere curiosity, was doubtful. At least that's what I thought.
At this point, very early in our careers, no one has yet called me a failure. But I think I can definitely foresee a time when some people will think that of me. I'm not sure I will particularly care, but I would definitely be tempted to think that those people just don't understand. And I might be further tempted to think that it might be because they are not capable of understanding, which assessment of their capabilities would be unfair if I had not, in the first place, given them a chance to understand by explaining myself. I usually dislike having to explain myself, since I tend to feel that only those who truly know me would be able to understand. But in this case, I think, an exception will have to be made.
The GP According To Juan Just recently, I had dinner with some med school friends. One of them, who is currently studying for the USMLE, asked the rest of us what our plans were. Before we could reply, he added, "
Basta ayaw lang gyud mo pag-GP. Don't deteriorate!"
The tendency to view General Practitioners, and even Family Medicine specialists, as inferior is not uncommon. It is reinforced by the practice of many GPs/FMs to admit patients under their own services (that is, the GP/FM is the patient's main doctor) while leaving actual management of the patient's problems to other specialists with whom the patient is co-managed. This awful practice makes people think of GPs as inutile, and FMs as only a bit better.
But I don't believe that is necessarily the case.
Broadly speaking, a general practitioner can still be excellent in his practice of medicine. True, there are a lot of cases beyond his capabilities. Initial management of a stroke, for example, would require referral to a neurologist. A myocardial infarction would necessitate a cardiologist. But the same would be just as true if one was, say, a pulmonologist. Specialists still refer patients to each other. One cannot know everything. What is important is for a doctor to know what he can and cannot do, to be aware of his limits, to be prudent in decision-making, to act for the patient's good at all times, and to be fair -- to refrain from demanding professional fees when he hasn't done anything significant.
The Case for "Underachievement" Mostly, when I mention the possibility of general practice, people say it's "
sayang," when I have the potential of being a good specialist. Crazy, but only a few people ever stop to think that I might actually have the potential of being a good generalist. (So thanks, Tonette, for saying my patients would be lucky. Hehe! But I still have much to learn.)
I can't say I blame them. Society has been conditioned to think that specialists are better than generalists, and subspecialists better than specialists, in the same way that neurosurgeons are regarded with more awe than are general surgeons, and those who have trained in America are more capable than those who have trained locally, or, heck, in the same way that doctors are held in higher esteem than janitors, and being a president is better than being a mayor. When God knows we need them all! For myself, I would rather be Tommy Osmena or Sonny Belmonte than Gloria Arroyo, I would think more of a kind janitor than a doctor with
bati'g batasan, and I would rather be Dr. Arco than...well, let's not go there.
There is always a pressure to achieve more, to
be more. However high up you've gone, there will always be something higher that you can aspire to, if heights are your cup of tea. For me, though, what's more important is to be good at whatever you are doing. Mediocrity, rather than underachievement, is for me the worse enemy, and excellence, rather than achievement, the worthier goal.
Bigger and brighter does not necessarily mean better. The Sun is no Betelguese but it's all we have and, for the solar system's everyday purposes, it's enough.
Purposes Having thus set aside as invalid the notion that I
have to be a specialist if I am to be anything worth a damn, I then proceeded to ask myself if I
want to be one. And the answer to that was: I didn't particularly mind, either way.
(Which wasn't very helpful.)
So I tried another question: what did I want my daily schedule to be like ten years from now?
This is what I came up with: Wake up. Fix breakfast for the family.
Have breakfast with the family. Go to the clinic. Maybe have lunch with my parents. Spend a couple of hours doing things for myself, like reading a book, or having coffee with friends, or shopping, or writing (ideally, a column for a local paper, but a blog will do). Back to the clinic. Fix dinner. Spend quality time with my family. Sleep (and
not have to wake up because of a patient). Do fun things on weekends. Travel. Sit on the porch and contentedly watch the world go by.
(I will
not be a hypocrite and add stuff like "cleaning the house." I am
awful at cleaning. Luckily, allergic rhinitis gives me a perfectly valid excuse. Haha!)
Rounds? Updates from residents? No, thanks. I'd rather spend all that time with my family. I joke about wanting to be a part-time doctor and part-time housewife, but, well, jokes are said to be half-meant. If my kids or husband ever feel that I don't have enough time for them,
then I would feel like a failure.
Choices Well, then, I've ruled out inpatient work. By choice, not circumstance.
The thing is, most residency training programs I know -- for IM and FaMed, having ruled out OB and Pedia a long time ago, and Surgery having pretty much ruled
me out, hehe, but, well, not that I was actually interested; anyway, most programs I know -- focus on inpatient work. Which, considering the "blood, sweat and tears" that a resident puts in (just read
Brian), seems pretty pointless if I'm not actually gonna be using what I learn [the hard way]. I mean, I'm not gonna be computing anion gaps in my little clinic, am I?
The way I see it, the only reason for my going into residency right now -- with the residency options available -- is because of the preconceived notion that
that's what doctors do after passing the board. If I had found a training program in Cebu that focused solely on outpatient diagnosis and management, I would have jumped right in. But there is none that I know of.
(I recently asked Dr. Berdin, one of my teachers at CIM who is also a practicing FM, about the "alternative pathway" for Family Medicine, and, as far as I understood what he said, he described it as a doctor with a "community-based" practice undergoing a sort of preceptorship. It sounds cool -- I get to build my own practice, but at the same time I get guidance from a mentor with more experience. However, Dr. Berdin says it isn't being done in Cebu. Yet.)
The Game Plan So. I haven't really closed my doors to going into a residency training program, but, as of now, there just aren't any interesting prospects out there. And just as I don't mind specializing in something, I certainly wouldn't mind staying a GP either. I figure, all I want to do anyway is to have my own little clinic in Talamban, and most of my prospective patients probably couldn't afford a specialist's fees.
This, then, is my game plan.
I'm going to set up my own clinic -- the Solera Primary Care Clinic. (I even have a name for it! Haha! What I'm trying to say is,
I've got a plan, guys. And it's a concrete plan, not castles in clouds. Don't worry about me so much.)
(Potential slogans: (1) Quality health care for all. (2) I did not become a doctor for those who can afford specialists. Go away.(3) If you don't trust me, don't bother me.)(I'm kidding!)
BUT I won't be a
chipipay sort of doctor. I'll give my patients FAQ handouts on whatever
sakit they have. I'll have a waiting area with reading materials. (It's a coin toss on the TV.) I'll even put up a coffee shop next door. (Hehe! Maybe.) My records will be computerized. And I'll
spend time with my patients. I'll explain their illnesses to them. I'll be nice. :-)
However, since I can't set up a clinic until next year at the earliest (it's a long story), I'm working full time at an HMO, to build capital and pay my bills and stay solvent. In reverse order.
And I'm trying to learn as much as I can (and as far as my attention span allows).
This I guarantee: if I stay a GP, I'm gonna be the best @#$%^&* GP I know.
I'm gonna be a good doctor, and a good wife, and a good mother, and a good daughter, and a good sister, and If I do all that, I will
never feel like a failure.
And if people still can't understand, they have no more excuses.